As “Big Brother” host Julie Chen says … always expect the unexpected.

On May 16, news broke that one of the show’s stars, Memphis Garrett, who appeared on seasons 10 and 22, was arrested in Florida on charges of swindling the state of Florida out of a hefty amount of money.

According to TMZ, Broward Sheriff’s officials confirmed to the publication that Garrett was arrested on Thursday, May 15, on a warrant issued by the Department of Revenue.

The reality star, who came in second place during his original run on “Big Brother” in 2008, has been accused of owing the state of Florida over $50,000 in unpaid taxes from his businesses.

As of Friday, May 16, the 42-year-old reportedly remains behind bars, with his bond set at $15,000.

Garrett, who later returned to “Big Brother” for its all-star edition in 2020, faces a second-degree felony for theft of state funds.

Florida is accusing the restaurateur of collecting $55,366.77 worth of sales taxes between November 2022 and October 2024 through his Poke House Lauderdale and No Man’s Land Miami LLCs and failing to pay the taxes to the state.

And if that wasn’t enough, Garrett’s name has already been in the headlines since 2024 when he filed for divorce from his “Big Brother 22” co-star, Christmas Abbott.

In the divorce filing, obtained by TMZ, the reason for the split was cited as “irreconcilable differences,” and it was argued that Abbott should not be awarded alimony.

“It is unfortunate that the actions and intentions of individuals involved in this situation have led to the exposure of personal and sensitive information,” Abbott told the publication at the time of the divorce announcement.

“I believe that matters of this nature should be resolved in a private and respectful manner,” she added. “I ask for privacy at this time to focus on my family.”

Garrett also commented, telling “BB” fans he was shaken by their relationship’s end.

“My heart hurts. I did not want to have to file for divorce. I was doing everything in my power to work on our marriage. I only wish the very best in life for her and [her son] Loyal,” he said.

Their conflict outside the “Big Brother” house wasn’t entirely shocking to fans, though, considering their dynamic on “All Stars” also included controversial interactions and accusations of insensitivity toward other houseguests, specifically Da’Vonne Rogers and David Alexander.

Although Garrett’s legal situation is likely the last thing the reality star wants to go through right now, he’s not the only “BB” facing legal woes.

In early 2025, Mike “Boogie” Malin was also arrested after allegedly shoplifting from multiple CVS stores in the San Fernando Valley region of Los Angeles.

According to a report from PEOPLE, the “BB 2” star was caught by an employee at the first CVS and returned the item after being confronted. He later fled in his vehicle and headed to a different location.

Burbank police officers told the publication that when they first searched the area for Malin, they found his car running with nobody inside. However, he was detained shortly after returning to his vehicle.

Malin’s 2025 mishap wasn’t his first arrest, either. In 2019, the “BB” legend was arrested and found guilty of felony stalking his former co-star Will Kirby.

The Blast previously covered Malin’s run-in with the law, which reportedly occurred after Kirby denied the chance to be on “The Amazing Race” with Malin. His refusal sent Malin into a spiral, who reportedly sent Kirby disturbing text messages and emails over the situation.

Receiving the messages as a threat to his family, Kirby contacted the LA Police Department and the FBI, leading to Malin’s arrest. Kirby was granted a restraining order, and Malin was sentenced to two years’ probation and ordered to pay the former $44,000.

The pair first met in 2001 during the iconic show’s second season. They later returned to the program in 2006 for season 7, which Malin eventually won. He returned once again in 2012 for season 14; however, he was eliminated early on, never reaching the season’s jury.